top of page

A Full Suite of AI Agents Helping Your Dental Practice

All-in-one AI front office handles calls, recalls, reminders, rescheduling, recording, and insurance checks and claims.

Search

Open Dental vs. Dentrix: 2025 Reviews, Ratings, and a Buying Guide

  • Maxillo Team
  • Aug 28
  • 5 min read

Choosing a dental practice management software is not just a technical decision; it is a choice about the philosophy that will run your practice. In today's market, no comparison makes this clearer than Open Dental vs. Dentrix. This is not just a feature-for-feature battle. It is a clash between a traditional, proprietary giant and a flexible, community-driven powerhouse.


Open Dental vs. Dentrix. A buying guide.

On one side, you have Dentrix, the long-established market leader from Henry Schein One, representing a conventional, single-vendor solution. On the other, you have Open Dental, the powerful, open-source alternative that has become a favorite among tech-savvy dentists who demand control and value.


Which approach is right for your practice? This guide dissects the fundamental differences in cost, features, and user experience, based on extensive third-party research and user reviews, to help you make an informed decision.


Meet the Contenders: Open Dental vs. Dentrix, A Tale of Two Systems


Understanding the core identity of each software is the first step in choosing the right one.


Dentrix (Henry Schein One)


Dentrix is a comprehensive, widely used system backed by one of the biggest players in the dental industry [1]. It operates as a closed ecosystem, offering a massive suite of its own tools and "Dentrix Connected" products.


  • Ideal User: Research suggests Dentrix is a fit for established practices that prefer a traditional vendor relationship and have the budget for a premium, all-in-one solution where support and features are managed by a single company [22].


Open Dental


Open Dental is unique in the market as an open-source platform. This gives practices unprecedented control over their software and, most importantly, their data [4]. It is known for its powerful customization and transparent pricing.


  • Ideal User: Open Dental is built for practices of any size, from startups to large DSOs, that value flexibility, data ownership, and cost-effectiveness. It is particularly favored by practice owners who are comfortable with technology and want to tailor a system precisely to their workflow [22].


Head-to-Head: The Feature & Philosophy Breakdown


The most significant differences between Dentrix and Open Dental are not just in their features, but in their entire business philosophy.

Category

Dentrix

Open Dental

Cost & Pricing Model

Opaque & Bundled. Pricing is not public. Users report high upfront costs and an "eServices" model where essential features like patient texting cost extra [23, 26, 27].

Transparent & Affordable. A low, publicly listed monthly support fee. No vendor lock-in and no extra charges for core features [4, 22].

Customization

Limited. Operates as a closed, proprietary system with limited ability to tailor workflows or reports [1].

Nearly Unlimited. As open-source software, it offers immense customization for reports, charting, and workflows to fit any practice style [22, 26].

Data Access

Proprietary. Your practice data is stored in a proprietary format. Accessing it for use with other systems can be complex and costly [22].

Open & Direct. You have complete, direct access to your practice data. You truly own your information [4].

User Interface (UI)

Polished & Traditional. Generally considered user-friendly by its base, with a familiar, polished interface [28].

Functional & Powerful. The interface is highly functional but can have a steeper learning curve due to its vast number of options. Some users find it less modern visually [26].


The core conflict is one of control versus convenience. Dentrix offers the convenience of a single, albeit expensive, vendor managing everything. Open Dental offers the control to build, adapt, and own your system at a fraction of the cost.


The Voice of the Community: User Reviews & Ratings


Third-party reviews and online dental communities, like Reddit's /r/Dentistry, provide a clear picture of user satisfaction. Open Dental consistently emerges as a community favorite.

Platform

G2 Rating

The Good (Common User Praise)

The Bad (Common User Complaints)

Dentrix

4.1 / 5 [28]

Comprehensive features, good customer support.

Expensive, slow performance, costly add-on model, having to pay extra for training [26, 28].

Open Dental

4.8 / 5

Unbeatable value, immense customization, excellent and responsive customer support, active and helpful user community [22, 26].

The learning curve can be steep due to its vast feature set. The user interface is powerful but considered less modern by some [26].

The sentiment, particularly among practice owners, leans heavily in favor of Open Dental. It is frequently recommended on forums as the best server-based system available, with users consistently highlighting its value and the freedom it provides from vendor lock-in [26]. While Dentrix support is often rated positively, the high costs associated with the software and its add-ons are a significant point of contention for its users.


The Bottom Line: Which System Aligns With Your Practice?



Based on available research, the choice between these two systems is a strategic one that reflects your practice's core values.


  • Choose Dentrix if: You want a long-established, single-vendor solution and are willing to pay a premium for its integrated ecosystem and support structure. It is a safe, traditional choice for practices that prefer to avoid deep technical customization.

  • Choose Open Dental if: You prioritize flexibility, data ownership, and long-term cost-effectiveness. It is the clear choice for practice owners who want to control their own technology and are comfortable tailoring a powerful system to their exact specifications.


Make an Informed Decision


Your practice management software is the engine of your business. This choice will shape your daily operations, your team's efficiency, and your financial health for years to come. Ultimately, Open Dental vs. Dentrix depends on your practice and its particular needs.


Ready to see how these two systems stack up against the broader market, including modern cloud-based alternatives? Dive into our [Interactive Buyer's Guide to Dental Practice Management Software] to analyze features, compare costs, and find the perfect software for your practice's unique goals.


Sources

1 "Dentrix Practice Management Software," Henry Schein. https://www.dentrix.com/

2 "What is Dental Practice Management Software?," CareStack. https://carestack.com/dental-practice-management-software

3 "The Ultimate Guide to Dental Practice Management Software," Dental Whale. https://www.dentalwhale.com/blog/the-ultimate-guide-to-dental-practice-management-software

4 "What is Dental Practice Management Software?," Open Dental. https://www.opendental.com/resources/article/what-is-dental-practice-management-software

6 "Dental Practice Management Software," Adit. https://www.adit.com/dental-practice-management-software

7 "Dental Software," Weave. https://www.getweave.com/dental-software/

10 "DentiMax Software," DentiMax. https://dentimax.com/

12 "Open Dental Imaging Software," DentiMax. https://dentimax.com/dentimax-imaging/open-dental-imaging-software/

13 "Dental Practice Management Software Buyer's Guide," Software Advice. https://www.softwareadvice.com/dental/buyerview/

15 "On-Premise vs. Cloud-Based Dental Software," tab32. https://www.tab32.com/blog/on-premise-vs-cloud-based-dental-software

17 "Cloud vs. Server: Which is More Secure?," Curve Dental. https://www.curvedental.com/blog/cloud-vs-server-which-is-more-secure

18 "On-Premise vs. Cloud," CareStack. https://carestack.com/blog/on-premise-vs-cloud

19 "Cloud vs. Server," Curve Dental. https://www.curvedental.com/blog/cloud-vs-server

20 "AI-Powered All-in-One Dental Practice Management Software," CareStack. https://carestack.com/features/ai-powered-dental-practice-management-software

22 "The Best Dental Practice Management Software of 2024," eAssist Dental Solutions. https://dentalbilling.com/blog/best-dental-practice-management-software/

23 "Dentrix eServices," Henry Schein. https://www.dentrix.com/products/eservices

24 "Dentrix Pricing," Henry Schein. https://www.dentrix.com/products/dentrix/pricing

25 "Dentrix Pricing, Demo, Reviews, Features," Software Advice. https://www.softwareadvice.com/dental/dentrix-profile/

26 User Discussions on /r/Dentistry, Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/Dentistry/

27 "What is the cost of dental practice management software?," Dental Economics. https://www.dentaleconomics.com/practice/article/16387094/what-is-the-cost-of-dental-practice-management-software

Comments

bottom of page